That engine should'nt cause too much problem, even with a couple of hundred horsepower at the tyres, and an open type diff will be cheaper too.
The cone type can be machined to revive a worn unit, but if the gears themselves are damaged or the bearings are noisy then you may as well bolt in a known good replacement.
I use an open diff on my relatively strong 440 and although its impossible to floor it in 1st and 2nd, even 3rd if cornering, it still drives nice, and with a 4 speed too, so i would'nt worry too much
Johns a good bloke to deal with as well, knows his stuff thats for sure